Antall József szerk.: Orvostörténeti közlemények 93-96. (Budapest, 1981)

TANULMÁNYOK - Gurevics, S. A.: Patográfiai módszer az orvostörténelemben (orosz nyelven)

KHX MeToflOB. ITaTorpad)HHecKHÜ aHajiH3 HMeeT CBOH rpaHHUbi, nejiH, HanpaBjieHHOCTb, H HMËHHO C 3THX n03HII,HH JJOJIXeH pa3BHBaTbCil H npHHOCHTb nOJIb3y. KaKOBbi ace rpaHHUbi MeTo/ja H uejiecoo6pa3HocTb ero /JJIH npaxTHHecxoü MeaHE.HHW? npHBe/reHHoe B Hanajie craTbn onpe/rejieHne naTorpachnii Hy)KJjaeTc« B yTOHHeHHH. B coBpejvieHHOH MemruHHe no/j; naTorparJjHefi cjie/ryeT noHHMaTb BcecTopoHHee HCCjie/roBaHHe 3a6ojieBaHH5i BbiTjaioiueiicH TBopnecxoii JIHMHOCTH B CBeTe SBOJUOUHH MeJTHIIHHbl H C n03HUHH pa3BHTHiI nCHXOJK3THH H TOO OÖJiaCTH yCXyCCTB3, B KOTOpOH TpyjJ,HJiaCb H3yHaeMaiI JIHHHOCTb. TpaHHUbi naTorpa(j)HH, xax H rpaHHUbi MHOTHX mpyrnx BH/J,OB HayiHoro TBopnecTBa, onpenejmioTCíi jjpcraTOMHO ycnoBHO. MeTo/roM naTorpacpHHecxoro nccjieuoBaHHa nojTb3yioTCH B paôoTax, KOTopbie, cTporo roBopa, Hejib3fl Ha3BaTb «HHCTbiMH» naTorpa(|)Hí[MH, HanpHMep, B MeMyapHoií jimepaType Bpaneö HJIH npn Hcnojib30BaHHH Me/XHUHHOH jiHTepaTypHbix npoH3Bejj,eHHH c yneTOM 3a6ojieBaHHH HX aBTOpOB. Bee STD C03AaeT 3HaHHTejlbHbIH, XOTJ1 H HepaBHOMepHblH nOTOK TpyUOB naTorpadpMHecKoro xapaxTepa HJIH C 3aivieTHo pa3BHTbiMH naTorpathHHecxHMH 3jieMeHTaMH, MTO B nejioM CBH/jeTejibCTByeT o Heo6xo/j,HMocTH Taxoii JiHTepaTypbi. 3a,aaHH naTorpaqbHHecKoro nccjiezioBaHH«, paBHo xax ero BO3.MO»CHOCTH, npeHMymecTBa H rpaHHUbi /xHXTyeT nojioîxeHHe naTorparbnii Ha cTbixe onpeneJieHHOÖ OÖJiaCTH Me/iHHHHbl, HCTOpHH Me/JHHHHbl, HCXyCCTBOBe/J,eHH5I, nCHXOJIOrHH JIHHHOCTH H TBopnecTBa. IlaTorparhHHecxaii MeToflHxa o onpeaejieHHoii CTeneHH o6be/j;HHaeT B ce6e xjiHHHXo-aHaMHecTHMecxHH, xaTaMHecTHHecxHH, ncHXOJiorHnecxHH H coiiHajibHoncHxojiorHMecxHH nonxo/xbi, HTO npH/raeT paöoTaM MHOrocTopoHHiOK) jjocTOBepHocTb. BajKHeHiiiHMH jjocTOHHCTBaMH naTorpacbnii — 3TO cjie/xyeT no/jnepxHyTb — íiBjmeTCíi HajiHHHe öojibinoro xojiHHecTBa pa3Hoo6pa3Hbix HccjieijoBaTejibcxHx HCTOHHHKOB, oÔHJine MHoronjiaHOBbix HayMHbix paxypcoB. ITpaxTHHecxaa ueHHocTb naTorparhnfi onpe/jejuieTCfl B OCHOBHOM cjieayroiiiHMH acnexTaMH: 1. B HacToamee Bpeivia B XJIHHHHCCXOH Me/jHHHHe npoHCXo/iHT HHTeHCHBHbiîi nponecc ecTecTBeHHoro M HcxyccTBeHHoro naTOMop(bo3a — «cmoùKOZo u cyluecmeeHHozo u3MeneHUH xapaKtnepa onpedeneHHoü őo/ie3HU, mo eemb ee ceoücme u nponeneHuü nod enunnueM pa3AUHHbix gSaxmopoe epedbï» (M. B. MHJIHH, 1972, c. 35). Be/ryniHM rhaxTopoM HcxyccTBeHHoro naTOMOp(bo3a HBJiaeTca npHMeHeHHe axTHBHoii ÖHOJiorHMecxoH TepanHH. naTorpacpHHecxHe HcejienoBaHHJí B Bex axTHBHOH ÔHOJIOrHHeCXOH TepanHH n03BOJiaK)T npe/JCTaBHTb «MHCTyiO», 6jIH3XyK> X ÖHOJTorHHecxoH, xapTHHy 6ojie3HH, 6e3 nero MHorne xoHnenuHM MejjnnHHbi Tpy/THO CHHTaTb yCTOHHHBbIMH. Taxaa ÔHOJiorHiecxH «HHCTaa» xapTHHa nocjie/joBaTejibHoro pa3BHTKH Ty6epxyjie3a OT uieiiHoro jiHMfbaAeHHTa JTO jjHcceMHHHpoBaHHoro rbH6po3HO xaBepH03Horo nponecca B03HHxaeT, HanpHMep, npn H3yneHHH HCTOPHH 6ojie3HH xoMno3HTopa OpHAepHxa IUoneHa (C. A. rypeBHH, 1975): xax H3BCCTHO (J)H6po3H0-xaBepHO3HbiH Ty6epxyjie3 B HacTojiinee BpeMH BCTpenaeTca pe/ixo. 2. LTjio/roTBopHoe pa3BHTne MeAHnHHbi, xax H BCHXOH oőjiacTH Hayxn, MOîxeT npOHCxoiTHTb TOJibxo Ha ocHOBe flHajiexTHMecxoíí npeeMCTBeHHOCTH cTaporo H HOBoro, nocToHHHoro Hcnojib30BaHHif HCTopHHecxoro onbiTa. MHTCHCHBHOC HaxonjieHHe Me/jHnHHCXHX 3HaHHÍí c nocTpoeHHeM Ha HX OCHOBC OÖHJIHH Teopnií Tpe-