Antall József szerk.: Orvostörténeti közlemények 93-96. (Budapest, 1981)

TANULMÁNYOK - Gurevics, S. A.: Patográfiai módszer az orvostörténelemben (orosz nyelven)

TOJlKOBaHHe 3a60JieBaHHÍÍ H MeTO/JOB JieHeHHfl CO CTOpOHbl HCMe/IHIIHHCKHX cneiTHajTHCTOB no/inac npnBonHT K ouiHÖoHHbiM BbiBO/jaM, 3aTeMHJi5i HCTHHY. B coBeTCKOö MeAHUHHe o^KHBJieHHe HHTepeca Bpaneö K naTorpa(J)HHecKHM HCCjiejjOBaHHSM 3aMeTHO co BTopoH nojiOBHHbi mecTHJj;ecHTbix TO/JOB, Kor/ia 6biJi onyôJiHKOBaH pa/j, apKHX Me/nniHHCKHx paôoT, 6JIH3KHX K naTorpa<J)HHecKHM, JIH6O BKJiKDHaioiiiHX naTorparbHHecKHe pa3/j[ejibi. npoßojmaa TeHnemiHH naTorpa<J)HMecKMX B3rjiaaoB AjiböepTa HlBefinepa, A. E. JIHHKO H B. E. POKHOB B HCHXHaTpHiecKHX onepKax o 6ojie3Hiix HßaHa rpo3Horo (1965), H. B. Torojia (1966) H O T. PacnyTHHe (1974) aKneHrnpyioT KoppejiaiiHH ncnxHHecKHX fbaKTopoB H COUHaubHbix ycjioBHÎî. B HCCJieAOBaHHH «KaK yiviep Torojib» A. E. JIHHKO npoBo^HT pa3FpaHHMeHHe nepno/JOB TBopnecTBa nHcaTejia c BbujejieHHeM BpeMeHH nocjie 1839 ro/ia, Kor/ia «TBOpnecKoe Hanajio npHHHMaeT naTojiorHHecKHH xapaKTep» (A. E. JIHHKO, 1966, c. 94), Ha npHMepe aHajiH3a OJJHOTO 3a6ojieBaHHa ocBemaeT cocToaHHe ncHXHaTpHHecKoíí jjHaraocTHKH H TepanHH B POCCHH cepejjHHbi XIX BeKa. OiiHy H3 npHHHH HeacHocTH 3a6ojieBaHHa H. B. Toroira A. H. MOJIOXOB B CTaTbe «O napaHOÜe y H. B. Torona» (1967, c. 233) BHAHT B TOM, HTO «ncuxuampun etue HedocmamoHHo pa.3pa6omajia ncuxonamoAozwo, K Komopoü omnocumcR ezo ÔAumeAbHoe u nemunumo npomeKiuee 3a6oAeeaHue». B. E. POÎKHOB B nonyjiapHOM onepKe o «nocAedneM epeMemtfwee nocAednezo pyccKozo uapx» TpHropHH PacnyTHHe paccjviaTpHBaeT coHHajibHo-ncHxojiorHHecKHe H JIKHHOCTHWC MexaHH3Mbi noflBJieHHa «ny/ioTBopHa», cTaBHT pa/j, cymecTBeHHbix /j;jia ncnxoTepanHH BonPOCOB nCHXOJTOrHHeCKOH 3aUTHTbI, pOJIH THnH03a B H3yneHHH B3aMHOJieHCTBHa co3HaTejTbHoro H 6ecco3HaTejibHoro. 3nH3o/ibi 3a6ojieBaHHÍí H TBOpnecTBa <E>. KaqbKH, MHKejibaHA^cejio, M. A. Bpyôejia, M. K. HropjieHHca H3ynajiHCb C. BI. HeijyBOH (1970) npn HccjienpBaHHH OHeMpoH/JHbix COCTOHHHH. E. H. JlnxTeHmTeÖH (1974) Ha ocHOBe Me/iHKO-ncHxojiorHHecKoro aHamoa HCTOPHH 3a6ojieBaHHH MonapTa, M. M. KoHHioÖHHCKoro, H. C. TypreHeBa paCKpbiBaeT 6oraTCTBO ncHXOTepaneBTHHecKHX no/ixo/jpB, acneKTbi B3aHMOoTHomeHHii Bpana H öojibHoro, BaacHocTb TOHKOTO npoHHKHOBeHHa B ncHXOJiorHK) Taacejio cTpa/jaiomero nejioBeKa, npnxoAHT K 3HaHHTejibHbiM /jeoHTojiorHHecKHM BbiBoijaivr. Ocoôaa yôe/iHTejibHOCTb H yHHKajibHocTb «ITocoÔHa no MCJIHIIHHCKOH AeoHTojiorHH» E. H. JlHXTeHHiTeHHa no/jnepKHBajiacb B npetfHCJioBHH aKa/ieMHKa B. X. BacHjieHKo H peneH3HH aKaAeMHKa B. JJ,. IleTpoBa Ha 3Ty KHHry (1975). JJjia Toro, HToöbi o6i»eKTHBHO oneHHTb pojib H aKTyajibHOCTb naTorparhHHecKOro MeTOAa B coBpeMeHHoö Meij;HnHHe, cjienyeT npe>K/j;e Bcero yTBepjjHTb TOT oneBHflHbrâ HCXOAHblH Te3HC, HTO 6oJie3HCHHbie HepTbl MOTyT 6bITb oÔHapyjKeHbi y HeKOTopwx BbmaiOHTHXca jiHHHocTeíí, KaK OHH MoryT 6biTb oÖHapyaceHbi H y MHOTHX jirofleií. 3TO, omraKO, He o3HanaeT, HTO 6ojie3HeHHbie nepTbi, 6y/j;b TO coMaTHHecKHe HUH ncHXHHecKHe, 6e3ycji0BHO conyTCTByroT remiaM, TajiaHTaM, H HMeeT CMbicji KaKaa-jiHÔo KjraccHcbHKanHa B STOM HanpaBjieHHH. 3aBejjoMo cxeiviaTHHHo coe/iHHTab TaKîKe BO Bcex cjiynaax TBopnecTBo H ncnxHnecKHe aHOMajiHH. TaKaa CBa3b MoaceT nojiHocTbio oTcyTCTBOBaTb, a MoaceT npoaBjiaTbca B cjioacHbix rhopiviax. BaîKeH oőteKTHBHbiH B3rjTKA, aHajiH3 qbaKTOB, caMHX TBopnecKHX npoaBjieHHH H B Kaac/j;oM KOHKpeTHOM cjiynae KOHKpeTHbrâ HCTopHKO-KjiHHHHecKHH aHajiH3 xapaKTepa 3a6ojieBaHHa. CyniecTBeHHO oroBopHTb H onacHOCTb Apyroíí KpaitHocTH. OIIIHÖOHHO npnAaBaTb naTorpad)HaM CKOJib-jinöo Bceo6bervijnoni;ee 3HaneHHe cpe^H MCAHHHHCn