Folia Canonica 9. (2006)
STUDIES - Szabolcs Anzelm Szuromi: Canon Law Handbook by Ivo of Chartres
CANON LAW HANDBOOK BY IVO OF CHARTRES 109 far away from that in the Decretum’s context (e.g. ID 12.12). It supports clearly, that the Angers Ms 369 is a colligatum. However, it is our impression that the binder lost some quire when the manuscript was rebound. It is very possible, because the script style is the same on both afore-mentioned folios (lOOv, lOlr). This probable lost quire can be a reason for the break in the original context of the codex. The material of the Panormia ends with an unusual supplementary canon. The regular closing canon (IP 8. 136) is about the election of the Roman Pontiff,74 a canon falsely attributed to Pope Leo VIII (963-965).75 In Migne’s edition it continues with conciliar canons, basically from the Council of Lateran II (1139),76 but we know one example (Paris, Bibliothèque Nationale de France lat. 2472), which ends with supplementary material from the Council of Reims (1148)77 and from the Council of Lateran III (1 179).78 Here, in Angers Ms 369, there is only one supplementary canon from an unknown source, whose theme manifests the pastoral use of this codex,79 as is also supported by the condition of those particular parts of the manuscript which we explained. 1. Panormia or Decretum? The Angers Ms 369 deffmitly contains the textform of the Panormia, but at some places the intention of the copier or illuminator is not so clear. On fol. lOv is a nice red and dark brown ornamental ‘P’ at middle of the folio, which looks like a mark for the beginning of the new book. Continuing our reading until fol. 14v, we can find the sign of the explicit of Book 1, then the first canon of Book 2 in much simpler form, and also a hidden mark at the corner, “Incipit II”. This appearance is considerable, because the above mentioned elegant ‘P’ is the initial of that canon (Panis et calix non quilibet [...]) which is IP 1.123, but in the textual tradition of the Decretum this canon is situated at the very beginning of Book 2 (ID 2. I).80 Cer74Foil. 105r-105v: In sinodo congregata Romae in ecclesia S. Saluatoris (...) Si quis contra hanc apostolicam auctoritatem aliquid molietur, hunc excommunicationi subiacere decernimus, et, nisi resipuerit, inreuocabili exilio puniri, uel ultimis suppliciis feriri. Cf. Bruxelles, Bibi. Royal MS 1817, fol. 142v; BAV Vat. lat. 1360, fol. 88v. 75 Friedberg I. 241, note 224. 76PL 161. 1340-1341; cf. Edinburgh, National Library of Scotland, Adv. Ms. 18.8.6, foil. 101r-103v. 77 Foil. 106ra-107ra. 78 Foil. 107ra-107vb. 79Foil. 106r-106v: In septuagesima cantatur (...) predicauit. 80Fol. lOv: Panis et calix non quilibet, sed certa consecratione misticus fit nobis, non nascitur. Proinde, quod ita fit nobis, quamuis sit panis et calix, alimentum est resurrectionis, non sacramentum religionis; non quod benedicimus, gratiasque agimus Domino in omni eius munere, non tantum spirituali, ueram etiam corporali. (ID 2. 1 = IP 1. 123) cf. D. 2 c. 39 de cons.
