Braun Tibor, Schubert András (szerk.): Szakértői bírálat (peer review) a tudományos kutatásban : Válogatott tanulmányok a téma szakirodalmából (A MTAK Informatikai És Tudományelemzési Sorozata 7., 1993)

MARTIN RUDERFER: The Fallacy of Peer Review: Judgement without Science and a Case History

198 RUDERFER: THE FALLACY OF PEER REVIEW 198 Appendix S 26 April 1977 Dear Dr Ruderfer, Due to your actions, the time and effort spent on your paper has been quite large and, although our nine reviewers may be wrong, we have decided to terminate our consideration of this paper. There are other journals for such papers and, if your paper does have merit, it will be published somewhere. Yours truly, Editorial Staff.