Fogorvosi szemle, 2016 (109. évfolyam, 1-4. szám)

2016-03-01 / 1. szám

14

FOGORVOSI SZEMLE ■ 109. évf. 1. sz. 2016.

Gingivális indexek összehasonlítása (2.2 eredmények)

X. táblázat

Powered Manual Std. Mean Difference Std. Mean Difference

Study or Subgroup Mean SD Total Mean SD Total Weight

2.2.1 Loe & Silness Gl

Aass & Gjermo 2000

1,215

0,135

50

1,19

0,11

50

13,8%

Heasman 1999

1,55

0,21

25

1,64

0,22

24

12,4%

Stoltze & Bay 1994

0,9

0,045

20

1,1

0,085

18

9,2%

Subtotal (95% Cl)

95

92

35,4%

Heterogeneity: Tau2 = 1,54; Chi2 :

= 36,21, df = 2

(P< 0,00001);

I2 = 94%

Test for overall effect: Z

= 1,32 (P

= 0,19)

2.2.2 Lobene mod. Gl

Van der Weijden 1994

0,8

0,24

42

0,94

0,26

35

13,3%

Subtotal (95% Cl)

42

35

13,3%

Heterogeneity: Not applicable

Test for overall effect: Z

= 2,38 (P

= 0,02)

2.2.3 BOP (Ainamo & Bay)

Dentino 2002

0,134

0,092

76

0,155

0,094

81

14,4%

Mantokoudis 2001

0,24

0,244

24

0,243

0,244

24

12,4%

Subtotal (95% Cl)

100

105

26,8%

Heterogeneity: Tau2 = 0,00; Chi2 = 0,41, df = 1 (P = 0,52); I2 = 0%

Test for overall effect: Z = 1,25 (P = 0,21 )

2.2.4 BOMP (van der Weijden)

Rosema 2008 0,57 0,36 37 0,61 0,285 39 13,4%

Subtotal (95% Cl) 37 39 13,4%

Heterogeneity: Not applicable

Test for overall effect: Z = 0,53 (P = 0,59)

2.2.5 Papillary Bl (Mühlemann)

McCracken 2004 0,97 0,2742 16 0,77 0,2742 16 11,1%

Subtotal (95% Cl) 16 16 11,1%

Heterogeneity: Not applicable

Test for overall effect: Z = 1,94 (P = 0,05)

Total (95% Cl) 290 287 100,0%

Heterogeneity: Tau2 = 0,34; Chi2 = 45,74, df = 7 (P < 0,00001); I2 = 85%

Test for overall effect: Z = 1,47 (P = 0,14)

Test for subgroup differences: Chi2 = 9,74, df = 4 (P = 0,04), I2 = 58,9%

IV, Random, 95% Cl IV, Random, 95% Cl

0,20 [-0,19, 0,59] -0,41 [-0,98, 0,15] -2,93 [-3,87, -1,98] -0,98 [-2,44, 0,48]-0,56 [-1,01,-0,10] -0,56 [-1,01,-0,10]

♦-0,22 [-0,54, 0,09] -0,01 [-0,58, 0,55] -0,17 [-0,45, 0,10]

i-0,12 [-0,57, 0,33] -0,12 [-0,57, 0,33]

0,71 [-0,01, 1,43] 0,71 [-0,01, 1,43]-0,34 [-0,79, 0,11]

♦-4-2 0

2

4

Favours powered Favours manual