Tanulmányok Deák Ferencről - Zalai Gyűjtemény 5. (Zalaegerszeg, 1976.)

HANÁK PÉTER: DEÁK ÉS A KIEGYEZÉS KÖZJOGI MEGALAPOZÁSA (A Pragmatica Sanctio újraértelmezése) - DEÁK UND DIE STAATSRECHTLICHE UNTERMAUERUNG DES AUSGLEICHS

XHH. TaKHM 0Ópa30M CTOpOHHHKH 4eaKa B 1861 TOfly npH 3aiUHTe 3aK0HH0ÍÍ OCHOBW 1848 roaa HCXOAHAH H3 ilparMaTHqecKOH caHKijHH, ccbiAaacb Ha STOT ApeBHHH, OŐH3bIBaK)UlHH B paBHOH Mepe OÖe CTOpOHbl „OCHOBHOH flOrOBOp", oTBepraa KaK OKTHÖpbCKHH annAOM 1860 rofla, TaK H HMnepcKyio KOHCTHTyLJHK), OKTpOHpOBaHHyiO $eBpaAbCKHM naTeHTOM 1861 TOfla. B 1860-e roflbi, Koraa KpH3HC CHCTCMM Heoa6coAK>TH3Ma cTaA xpoHnqecKHM, „CTapOKOHCepBaTOpbl" CTSAH npHŐAHÍKaTbCH K KpyiKKy 4

eaKa

> H T0T nocKOAbKy cyujecTBOBaHHe MoHapxHH 0Ka3aA0Cb npoqHOH noAHTHqecKoii peaAbHOCTbK) — npHÖAH3HACH K corAameHHK) Ha noHBe Ay

a

AH3Ma. FlparMaTHqecKyio caHKijHK) nocTeneHHo nepeoijeHHBaAH. JleaK, noAeMH3Hpyn c aBCTPHHCKHM ropHCTOM BeHLiAOM AycTKaHflA, CHaqaAa npH3HaA, MTO FIparMaTHqecKan caHKijHH co3flaAa „TecHyio" nepcoHaAbHyio, a no3flHee, B 186^ roay, BO BpeMH neperoBopOB c flOBepeHHbiM nocpe^HKKOM KopoACfl, corAacHACH c HeOÖXOflHMOCTbK) COBMeCTHOrO BeflÉHHH OŐUIHX #eA. IlpH 3TOM OH CCbIAaACfl H Ha nparMaTHHecKyio caHKijHio, a no3AHee B 1866—1867 ro/ibi, BO BpeMH 3aKAioqeHHH CorAauieHHH no cyiiiecTBy HCTOAKOBbiBaA npeíKHee COCAOBHOC corAauieHHe B KaqecTBe peaAbHofi yHHH. BeHrepcKHe noAHTHqecKne pyKOBO#HTeAH Bbmy>K#eHbi ÓWAH ccbiAaTbCíi H ocHOBbiBaTbca Ha IlparMaTHqecKyjo caHKijHio noTOMy, HTO HenocpeacTBeHHblH npaBOBMH HCTOHHHK HenpepbIBHOCTH B OŐAacTH npaBa (AerHTHMHOCTH) — 1848 rofl He 6biA npnroflHOH 6a3ofi #AH corAameHHH. HeAb3í( ÖblAO flOCTHrHyTb TOrO, HTOŐbl MOHapX H aBCTpO-HCMeiJKHe pyKoBO^HTeAH npHHHAH ero noAHOCTbio, a HanocpeflCTBeHHyio ero peBH3Hio He npnH^Aa 6w BeHrepcKaa HaijHOHaAbHaa oóiuecTBeHHOCTb. TaKHM oőpa30M TpeóoBaAacb nocpeflHHqecKaíi HAOI, npoMeiKyTOqHafl npaBOBan ocHOBa H TaKOBofi Ha oöiijeHMnepcKOM ypoBHe Ka3aAacb riparMaTHqecKafl caHKriHH. Pa3yMeeTca, 3aHOBO HCTOAKOBaHHWH „OCHOBHOH flOrOBOp", H3 KOTOporo yJKe MOIKHO ÖblAO „BbiqHTaTb" HMnepcKyio oőiuHOCTb, HeoöxoAHMbix oöuiHX AeA H oöniero HX BeaeHHíi, HHMMH CAOBaMH, c ero noMorgbio MOÍKHO 6biAO MOflHCpHiiHpoBaTb anpeAbCKHe 3aK0Hw 1848 ro/ia. 3TO HOBoe TOAKOBaHHe ocyrgecTBHA 4

eaK

» HMeHHO OH c noMoiijbio HOBoro rocyaapcTBeHHO-npaBOBoro oőocHOBaHHH nepe6pocHA MOCT Meaífly 1848 H 1867 ro/iaMH. 3TO 6biAa MOHapxnqecKaH KOHijenIIHÍI, oHa npHHHAa noflqHHeHHOCTb HHTepecoB BeHrpHH OCHOBHMM HHTepecaM HMnepHH, BMecTe c TeM oőecneqnBaAa KOHCTHTyynoHHyK) aBTOHOMHio cTpaHw H TOAKOBaAa riparMaTHqecKyio aBTOHOMHio cTpaHw H TOAKOBaAa llparMaTHqecKyio caHKLiHio B AHÓepaAbHOM ayxe, cooTBeTCTByroiueM 6yp>Kya3HbiM yCAOBHHM. TaKan nocpeflHHqecKan naen TpeóoBaAacb B cAyqae Bcex 6ypaíya3Hbix peBOAioriHOHHbix npeo6pa30BaAHH MeiKfly paflHKaAbHbiM no6e#OHOCHbiM 3TanOM H B ÓOAbUieH CBOefi qaCTbK) KOMnpOMHCCHbIM 3aKAK)qHTeAbHbIM 9TanoM — noAO^íeHHeM noKoa. CneiiHípHqecKOH qepTofi BeHrepcKoro 6yp>Kya3Horo npeo6pa30BaHHH, xapaKTepHofi #AH MbiuiAeHHH pyKOBoaniiiero CAOH 6WAO TO, HTO OHH qepnaAH AerHTHMH3aiiHio — B oTAHqne OT aHrAHqaH H (ppaHHy30B — He H3 (pHAOcoípHH, He H3 6ypHiya3Ho5 (pHAOCO'pHH npaBa H 6yp*Kya3HOH TeopHH o rocyflctpcTBe, a H3 KjpHflHqecKOH npaKTHKH H HCTopnqecKH OÓOCHOBaHHoro rocyaapcTBeHHoro npaBa.