Hedvig Győry: Mélanges offerts a Edith Varga „Le lotus qui sort de terre” (Bulletin du Musée Hongrois des Beaux-Arts Supplément 1. Budapest, 2001)
ANDREY O. BOLSHAKOV: Osiris in the Forth Dynasty Again? The false door of 'Intj, MFA 31.781
Dynasty (false door of TtwIMsnj in the tomb of his father Ttw/K3(j)-n(j)sw.t, G 2001). 59 60 7. The back of the chair of Jntj is covered by a cushion. According to N. Cherpion, such representations appear under Snefru, are rare prior to Isesi, and predominant under Unis and later. 61 However, almost all the tombs dated by Cherpion back to the Fourth - first half of the Fifth Dynasty 62 are actually not earlier than the reign of Niuserra. 63 a) N(j)r nh-snfr-w(j), Dahshur 8. Cherpion's dating: reign of Snefru. Traditional dating: Sixth Dynasty. 64 b) Snfr-w(j)-htp(.w), G 3008. Cherpion's dating: reign of Snefru. Traditional dating: Sixth Dynasty. 65 c) K3(.j)-hj.f, G 2136. Cherpion's dating: reign of Cheops. Traditional dating: middle Sixth Dynasty. 66 d) Nfr, G 4761. Cherpion's dating: reign of Cheops. Traditional dating: reigns of Unis - Teti. 67 e) ï>h.t(j)-htp(.w), Giza, West Field. Cherpion's dating: reign of Cheops. Traditional dating: Sixth Dynasty. 68 " Simpson, op. cit. (note 23) Pt. I. of vol. IV, pi. 20, fig. 18. M For the list of the monuments see Harpur, op. cit (note 3), p. 331-332, and add the false door in the mastaba of Mst, Sixth Dynasty; Junker, op. cit. (note 34), p. 235, and the double false door of Kjj and Zi.t-Sd-ibd, Louvre E. 14.184, First Intermediate Period, Ch. Ziegler, Musée du Louvre, Département des antiquités égyptiennes. Catalogue des stèles, peintures et reliefs égyptiens de l'Ancien Empire et de la Première Période Intermédiaire, Paris 1990, pp. 244-252, eat. no. 45. 61 N. Cherpion, Mastabas et hypogées d'Ancien Empire. Le problème de la datation, Bruxelles 1989, p. 30, critère 6. Cherpion, op. cit. (note 61), pp. 151-152. 63 On the workability of Cherpion's criteria in general see below, Supplement, §1. M PM IIF, p. 892; Harpur, op. cit. (note 3), p. 279:611. PM IIF, p. 96; cf. Harpur, op. cit. (note 3), p. 269:214 - the first three decades of Pepi II. The early dating is impossible also due to the presence of the field works scenes on the east wall they emerged there only in the late Fifth Dynasty, see A. O. Bolshakov, op. cit. (note 14), Tbl. 1. <•<• pM up, p 76; c f Harpur, op. cit. (note 3), p. 271:278 - middle reign of Pepi II. The early dating is impossible also due to the presence of the field works scenes on the east wall - they emerged there only in the late Fifth Dynasty, see Bolshakov, op. cit. (note 14), Tbl. 1. 67 PM III 2 , p. 76; Harpur, op. cit (note 3), p. 267:126. The early dating is impossible also due to the presence of the list of offerings on the west wall and of the scene of the handing over of a lotus on the south wall - they emerged there only in the middle Fifth Dynasty, see Bolshakov, op. cit. (note 14), Tbl. 1. 68 PM IIF, p. 49.
