Antall József szerk.: Orvostörténeti közlemények 93-96. (Budapest, 1981)

TANULMÁNYOK - Gurevics, S. A.: Patográfiai módszer az orvostörténelemben (orosz nyelven)

C uejibio H3yneHHH Bonpoca, HMeeT JIH reHHajibHocrb naTojiorHHecxyio ocHOBy HJiH OHa npeflCTaBjiaeT He6ojie3HeHHoe noBbinieHHe cnocoÖHOcTeM, JleBeHrJpejibrj, (1903) co3uaji flBeHafliíaTb naTorpaqbnH BbiztaroiUHXca xy,ao5KHHKOB, cpe^H KOTOpbix JleoHapflo nß. BHHHH, MHKejibaHji>Kejio, TnnnaH, Parhasjib, /J,K>pep, Tonb6eÖH, PyôeHC, Peivi6paH,irT. B 1907 Tojxy nun öojiee oôbeKTHBHoro H jiCHoro onHcaHHíi H3ivieHeHHH ncHxuKii npH Ty6epKyjie3e JlaHejib-JTaBacTHH B «LTcHxojiorHH öojibHbix Ty6epKyjie30M» Hcnojib30Baji aHajiH3 >KH3HH H TBopnecTBa BCJIHKHX ^eaTejieH HayxH, HCKyccTBa H jiHTepaTypbi, noKa3biBaa BjiHíiHHe 3a6ojieBaHHíí Ha jniHHOcTb H TBOpnecTBo HloneHa, MHJibToHa, JlasHHeKa, BlaToôpMaHa, UlHJiJiepa.* OueHHB LUHpOKHe B03MOÄHOCTH naTorpa(|>HHecKoro MeTo^a H ero nojie3HOCTb He TOJIbKO AJIJÏ MeflHHHHbl, AjIbÖepT UlBeÖIiep no OKOHHaHHH MeflHIIHHCKOrO (haxyjibTeTa B 1913 ro,n,y H36paji TeMoö AnccepTaiiHH HcaneaoBaHHe nocTynKOB ÍÍHcyca XpMCTa. PaccMaTpHBaa Xpncra, KaK peajibHO cymecTBOBaBinyio HCTOpHHecyKK) jiHHHOcTb, HlBeiiuep nocTaBHji nojx coMHeHne B3rjiíiu,bi Bpaneíí jxe JloocTeHa, BHHe-CaHrjie, Xnpnia o HajiHMHH BO Bcex nocTyraax Xpucra npH3HaKOB napaHoiwjibHoro 3a6ojieBaHHH c H^eaMM BCJIHHHH H npecjieAOBaHHíi, noKa3aji HCTOKH H coiiHajibHO-ncHXOJiorHMecKHe KopHH BJIHÎIHHÎÏ J/lHcyca, cyTb ero MeCCHaHCTBa (B. M. HOCHK, 1971). B nocjiemnie níiTbnecíiT jieT HaKonjiemrbie naTorpacpHHecKHe MaTepnajibr o 6ojie3HJix ^eflTejieii HCKyccTBa H jiHTepaTypbi cjiyacaT npe^MeTOM MHoroHHCjieHHbix nyöJiMKaiiHH B pa3Hbix cTpaHax Eßponbi H AMepuKH. HecMOTpíi Ha xpoHOJiorHHecKyio oTflajieHHOcTb MHorax HBjieHMH, Bpa^H BHOBb H BHOBb oőpainaioTCíi K HUM, BbWBHraa CBOH apryMeHramiM H TOMKH 3peHH5i H nojiynaii aKTyajibHbie Me^HHHHCKHe BbiBOflbi. B ,n,Ba,rruaTbie roAbi B ^MJiajxenb^mu T. Toynn H3/iaji cepnK> KHHr BOR 061HHM Ha3BaHHeM «KJIHHHHeCKHe ÖHOrparpHH», HMeBUiyiO OOJIblHOM ycnex. CoBceM He^aBHO, B 50—

70-e roßbi BHOBb BO3HHK noxoK JiHTepaTypbi o 6ojie3HH MouapTa H pe3KMe ^HCKyccHH no Bonpocy o BepojiTHOM oTpaBJieHHn ero CajibepH — TeMa, HHTepecoBaBuiaa eme A. C. ITyuiKHHa. OnyôjiHKOBaHa KHnra T. JXyßpL «KoHeHHO, MeHfl oTpaBHJiH» (1958), onpoBepraK>mai[ BepcHio o xpomineCKOH 6ojie3HH, 6y^To 6bi npHBeßineH K CMepra KOMno3HTopa. Bpana 3amiMaeT THnoTe3a o pTyTHOM oTpaBJieHHH Mouapra MacoHaMH. refí^ejiböeprcKHH yneHbiii A. TpefiTep (1958), cyMMHpoBaB B OÖIHHPHOH nepenHCKe MoiiapTa yxa3aHHfl Ha ero nacTbie 3a6ojieBaHH£, AHarHOcmipyeT B KOHCMHOM HTore xpoHHHeacyio 6oJie3Hb noneK c noneHHOH He^ocTaTOHHOCTbio, KaK npHHHHOö CMepTH. Me^Hi^HHCKHe rJ)aKTbi noMoraioT npoaHajiH3MpoßaTb H3MeHeHHii xapaKTepa MouapTa, CBii3aHHbie c ero 6one3HeHHOCTbK) H npoüBUBUiHecji B ero My3biKe. LTaTorpa(J)HHecKaH jiHTepaTypa o MonapTe — Hbme o/iHa H3 Hanőojiee MCTO^HHecKH penpe3eHTaTHBHbix. Hapiwy c paÖoTaivra o 6ojie3HH MoirapTa, cjie^yeT Ha3BaTb MOHorpa(J)Hio B. OopcTepa «BojiesHH BeTxoBeHa H cyac^eHHe o HHX B jiHTepaType» (1955), B KOTopoß ynoMHHaioTCH cBbiuie BocbMHfleciiTH naTorpafJpHHeCKHX HCCJieflOBaHHÍÍ 3a6oJieBaHHÍI KOMn03HTOpa. B OCHOBe KHHrH jiexHT £HCcepTainia, 3aLUHHj,eHHaa B 3eHKeH6eprcKOM HHCTHTyTe HCTOPHH MeAHU,HHbi BO OpaHKqbypTe; onepnpyH HMeKnrniMHCJi jiHTepaTypHbiMH AaHHbiMH o 6ojie3Hflx KOMH03HTopa, B. OopcTep KJiaccHfJpHHHpyeT HX no TpeM rpynnaM: npocTy^Hbie, yuiHbie, DKejiy^OMHbie. AHajiH3HpyK)Tca npHMHHbi myxoTbi BeTxoBeHa c B03* HeonpaBflaHHO, o^HaKO, BKHIOHEH B crmcoK öontHbix Ty6epKyne30M MoaapTa H IJJyôepTa.